Monday, May 28, 2012

The Crucible - Task 8

Question Chose another theme from The Crucible, and make a question Response Personal Belief: Which is more important, personal belief or what the community perceives as being correct?

Sunday, May 27, 2012

Question Homework – write a paragraph explaining the connection between the McCarthy era and the play. Be concise and prioritise your ideas. Think and plan before you write! Response The play, 'The Crucible', seems to have a very strong connection to the McCarthy era in the aspects of the storyline, actions by others and characters/people. The storyline behind both the play and McCarthy era is basically about people who are accused of something that is claimed as being 'bad' in society, and cannot escape the accusations even if they are innocent of the crime. The only true difference is that Miller's play focuses on the idea of witchcraft, whereas the McCarthy era revolves around communism. Miller is pointing out the echoes that he finds still in existence in the America of his time, being the central idea of innocent people being blamed for being or doing something that the community has been taught to perceive as wrong. As people who were accused of witches in the Salem trials never returned to the good reputation they had previously had, the same happened to the people who were accused of being communists. However instead of just their good name being destroyed, the accused people also had their career permanently ruined or were imprisoned. There is also a great connection between the characters of 'The Crucible' and the McCarthy era. In Millers play, he depicts people being accused of being witches or using witchcraft. This has the same idea as the McCarthy era, but people were accused of being communists or believing in communism, instead of witches or witchcraft. Also, Hollywood ten seem to be similar in action to those who refuse to confess to the crime of witchcraft in the Salem Trials. Therefore, Arthur Millers play, 'The Crucible' and the McCarthy era have a very strong connection in the aspects of the storyline, actions by others, and characters/people.

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 6

Question
Is John Proctor a hero or not? We have debated this in class. Now choose the most effective point in the argument for or against and write a paragraph on this point with a really effective topic sentence and evidence from the play in support. Include at least one correctly punctuated quotation. Post to your blog for tomorrow’s lesson.


Response

John Proctor displays many characteristics that define him as a hero, and can be found in the argument of the affair between Abigail and himself. Early in the script, readers discover that John has been in private intimacies with Abigail, however perhaps the events that occur after this event is what truly makes him a hero. The affair comes to knowledge when Abigail and John Proctor are speaking privately, and John says to her, “Abby... I’ll not be comin’ for you more” (p. 29). This quote provides the information to confirm the sins of John, however it is the way that he handles his mistakes that makes the goodness in him stand out. After this event, Proctor realised what sin he had created and does not commit lechery again. This is evident when John is alone with Abigail and had the opportunity to have another affair, however he says “...I will cut off my hand before I’;; ever reach for you again” (p. 21). Obviously John Proctor has good morals within his soul, if he has the decency to not continue on the affair that had begun. Classical heros also make mistakes, for example when Spiderman kissed another women other than Mary-Jane. Along with John not continuing the affair with Abigail, he also contains much guilt for what he did, and seeks forgiveness from both his wife, Elizabeth, and himself. He feels as though he has lost his soul from committing such a large sin when he is forced to sign his name confessing he has used witchcraft and he exclaims, “Because it is my name!...How may I live without my name? I have given you my soul; leave my name!” (p. 124). Readers also come across Johns agony in himself when he is speaking to his wife and she is telling him that it was partially her fault for his lechery, and he cries out, “No, I take my own [sins], my own!” (p. 119). Surely a good man should have self-guilt for the pain he had caused his wife to feel, and seek forgiveness from his wife. Overall, John Proctor is definitely a hero for partially his good morals, but there are many others examples that have not been spoken of. 

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 5

Question Why do you think Proctor decides to confess? Why does he change his mind? Give evidence for both answers. Post on your blog before Friday's lesson Response John originally decided to confess to the sin of using witchcraft, for the sole purpose of living with his wife. Before the witch trials and begun to occur in Salem, the relationship between John and Elizabeth had been awkward and tense. However, when John is deciding between confessing or not, Elizabeth realises the sin she has committed - Acting coldly towards her husband. This is shown when she exclaims to John, "...I have sins of my own to count. It needs a cold wife to prompt lechery." (pg. 119). This is a large turn in the relationship between the Proctors, as Elizabeth is forgiving John for his affair, claiming that it was equally her fault for the sin. She then continues to weep "...Forgive me, forgive me, John - I never knew such goodness in the world!" (pg. 119). When John realises how different his life would be with his renowned love for his wife, he makes a quick decision to confess, "I want my life." (pg. 120). One of the reasons, I believe, that Proctor changed his mind on confessing, if due to him previously making a quick decision, influenced by his wife, and not taking everything into consideration. John realises that he is sinning when he is asked to sign the document, confirming the idea that he is a witch. John then proclaims, "You have all witnessed [me confessing] it; what more is needed?" (pg. 124). You can begin to notice the strain in Proctors word, and that John is feeling unhappy with his previous decision. Later, when he is forced to sign his name in attempt to save his life he shouts, "... It is my name! I cannot have another in my life! Because I lie and sign myself to lies! Because I am not worth the dust on the feet of them that hang! How may I live without my name? I have given you my sole; leave me my name!" (pg. 124). This is the strongest quote in proving why Proctor changes his mind, as he realises what lies he is confessing, and realises how to set his soul free of these sins. In the end, John decides to have his name remain pure and full of goodness, therefore hanging for his innocence.

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 4

Question
Re-read the final scene between John and Elizabeth. Elizabeth refuses to advise her husband but she clearly has a point of view on his situation. In her heart, what does want him to do? What would she say to him if she could? Post to your blog before Monday's lesson.

Response
In Elizabeth's heart, she wants John to do what makes him happy. She would like to him alive, but if it means that John would be unhappy all his life, as he feels he has lied to God, there would be no point in him living. Elizabeth wants John to live, as she states "I    want     you    living,       John.     That's    sure." But then she continues to say that there is no greater judge under Heaven, and she wants him to do what he feels is right.  At the end of the scene, Goody Procter states, "He have his goodness now. God forbid I take it from him!". When she says this, she is saying that she respects Johns decision. If Elizabeth would say something to John if she could, before he went to his execution, I believe she would say...

"John, you have been a wonderful husband. However much I want you to be alive and well, it is safe to say that you'll travel to heaven when you have passed. I only want you to be happy, and if that means hanging for your goodness, let it be that. I know you are a good man John, and you don't need to prove it to me, but as long as this is what you want, I'm happy for you. If you would have lived, you would be dead inside for lying to god, and I commend you for doing what you feel is right, John. I love you."

The Crucible - Homework 3

Question
On page 116, Danforth says a long speech to Elizabeth, however she does not respond. Write what you feel Elizabeth would have replied, it should be around the same length as the paragraph that Danforth says.

Response
"Excellency, there be no need in me reasoning with my husband. It be is own choice to choose between lying to God, or hanging for his innocence. My husband be full of goodness within him, and yet you strive to see this. You take no evidence to accuse such a crime, yet you need a hand and a mouth full of evidence to proof their innocence. God watches over us, telling us that our lives are precious, yet here you are throwing away guilty-free peoples lives each day. Now, you ask me to plea for my husband to confess to a charge that he had not committed, asking him to lie to God. I feel softly towards my husband, and I do not want to behold him in confessing such a black sin, only to please me. You say that I may well be a witch as there be no tears in my eyes, but my sadness lies within. If I love my husband, I'd not let him be miserable in lying to god for my sake, I'd let him choose his own fate. If in gods name, John would prefer to die for his innocence and for the goodness to his name, let it be that. "

Friday, May 4, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 2

Question
The Crucible Act 1 In his introduction of John Hale starting on page 37, what attitude does Arthur Miller take to the belief in the devil/evil spirits? Write a paragraph response using quotations in support of your explanation. This is quite a difficult passage. You will need to read it carefully and give your response some thought. Post on your blog by Monday 8.20


Response
Arthur Miller takes a series of attitudes to the belief in the devil/evil spirits. He looks upon the devil as "a necessary part of a respectable view of cosmology" (pg 37). When Miller states this, he is meaning that with all the history and beliefs behind these so called, "evil spirits", it has become a part of society that cannot be forgotten. Even horror movies have taken the idea of these spirits and used it to scare audiences, and be afraid of the devil. Arthur Miller looks at the idea of the devil/evil spirits as not being a belief, but a necessity in life. Miller addresses that the devil is used as a weapon, "a weapon designed and used time and time again in every age to whip men into a surrender to a particular church or church-state" (pg 38). With this, I believe that Arthur Millers attitude is to think of the devil as not a "real spirit", but just an idea used to make citizens behave in a more godly manner. The church is using this concept of an evil spirirt in order to control the christian society. During the middle of John Hale's introduction, Miller states that the children of history still "sucks at the Devil's teats" (pg 38). We are so interested in this conspiracy, that when something out of the ordinary does occur, we find ourselves intregued that this idea may be a reality. We are feeding the idea of the devil by doing this, and while doing so we are bringing the belief of evil spirits to a larger community. Furthermore, in the last paragraph of John Hale's introduction, Miller explains that the "Communists in Russia, where women's fashions, for instance, are as prudent and all-covering as any American Baptist would desire" (pg 39). This quote is supporting the idea of the church controlling the surrounding community. By warning people of this evil spirit, the church can convince the community that they can avoid this by following a set of commandments. In this case, by using the devil as the consequence of dressing inappropriately, women learn to wear clothing that is all-covering. Overall, Arthur Miller's attitude to the belief of the devil/ evil spirits is quite a range of discussion, and oversights what the community have been taught to believe in, or not. 



Thursday, May 3, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 1

Question
Choose two characters - one to whom you respond positively and one to whom you respond negatively. What aspects of the text have positioned you to respond this way? You may want to consider representations, characterisation and voice. Quote in support.

Response
One character that I find myself responding positively towards is the character of Tituba, the domestic servant in the Parris household. Even though this woman dances, sings and chants, it is easily identifiable that her heart is in the right place. In the text, Tituba states that Abigail would "...beg me make charm..." (pg 46).The wording convinces me that Tituba only chants in the forest with the other girls as a way to make them happy, and free them of their plain lives for just a short moment. Tituba also displays her large heart when Betty is found in her bed, not waking up, and she says, "My Betty be hearty soon?" (pg 17) and then, "My Betty not goin' die..." (pg 17). When I read this in my mind, I can only imagine Tituba saying this with deep though, meaning and concern for Betty. With this, I feel that Tituba honestly loves Betty and cares for her as if it were her own daughter. One of the last aspects for me looking at Tituba in a positive fashion, is the fact that she does not confess to Parris of the girls dancing with her, although this may be for her own purposes. Overall, I feel that Tituba is genuinely a very caring character, and although she has her faults, she has a very large heart.

 On the other hand, I find myself responding negatively to the character of Abigail, the niece of Parris. The main purpose for my negative outlook on Abigail is due to the wording of both her speech and actions. In my opinion, I find Abigail to be very hostile towards others at times, irresponsible and a liar. In one section of the play, when Abigail is speaking to Mercy and Mary Warren about the incident at the woods the other night, she threats them by saying, "Let either of you breathe a word... and I will come to you in the black of some terrible night and I will bring a pointy reckoning that will shudder you" (pg 26). I feel this quote to be very harsh on the other girls, and positions me to look at the character of Abigail with a snarl on my face. I also find her to be irresponsible, mostly due to her unbelievably strong attraction to John Procter, a married man and father of three. Obviously I understand that there is a chemistry bound between them, however I feel that Abigail is doing an irresponsible act by trying to 'steal' him off another woman. Lastly, I don't appreciate the idea of Abigail, alongside Betty, accusing innocent people of witchcraft and even causing their death. An example of when Abigail accuses someone is when she exclaims to Parris and Mr. Hale, "I saw Goody Sibber with the devil!" (pg 49). Therefore, due to mostly the wording of the text, I respond to the character of Abigail in a negative manner because of the previous reasons.