Wednesday, May 16, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 5

Question Why do you think Proctor decides to confess? Why does he change his mind? Give evidence for both answers. Post on your blog before Friday's lesson Response John originally decided to confess to the sin of using witchcraft, for the sole purpose of living with his wife. Before the witch trials and begun to occur in Salem, the relationship between John and Elizabeth had been awkward and tense. However, when John is deciding between confessing or not, Elizabeth realises the sin she has committed - Acting coldly towards her husband. This is shown when she exclaims to John, "...I have sins of my own to count. It needs a cold wife to prompt lechery." (pg. 119). This is a large turn in the relationship between the Proctors, as Elizabeth is forgiving John for his affair, claiming that it was equally her fault for the sin. She then continues to weep "...Forgive me, forgive me, John - I never knew such goodness in the world!" (pg. 119). When John realises how different his life would be with his renowned love for his wife, he makes a quick decision to confess, "I want my life." (pg. 120). One of the reasons, I believe, that Proctor changed his mind on confessing, if due to him previously making a quick decision, influenced by his wife, and not taking everything into consideration. John realises that he is sinning when he is asked to sign the document, confirming the idea that he is a witch. John then proclaims, "You have all witnessed [me confessing] it; what more is needed?" (pg. 124). You can begin to notice the strain in Proctors word, and that John is feeling unhappy with his previous decision. Later, when he is forced to sign his name in attempt to save his life he shouts, "... It is my name! I cannot have another in my life! Because I lie and sign myself to lies! Because I am not worth the dust on the feet of them that hang! How may I live without my name? I have given you my sole; leave me my name!" (pg. 124). This is the strongest quote in proving why Proctor changes his mind, as he realises what lies he is confessing, and realises how to set his soul free of these sins. In the end, John decides to have his name remain pure and full of goodness, therefore hanging for his innocence.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Zoe, your argument is very well presented and written. Your points are clear and detailed. I like the quote where John quotes "Leave me my name!" good work.

    ReplyDelete