Tuesday, May 22, 2012

The Crucible - Homework 6

Question
Is John Proctor a hero or not? We have debated this in class. Now choose the most effective point in the argument for or against and write a paragraph on this point with a really effective topic sentence and evidence from the play in support. Include at least one correctly punctuated quotation. Post to your blog for tomorrow’s lesson.


Response

John Proctor displays many characteristics that define him as a hero, and can be found in the argument of the affair between Abigail and himself. Early in the script, readers discover that John has been in private intimacies with Abigail, however perhaps the events that occur after this event is what truly makes him a hero. The affair comes to knowledge when Abigail and John Proctor are speaking privately, and John says to her, “Abby... I’ll not be comin’ for you more” (p. 29). This quote provides the information to confirm the sins of John, however it is the way that he handles his mistakes that makes the goodness in him stand out. After this event, Proctor realised what sin he had created and does not commit lechery again. This is evident when John is alone with Abigail and had the opportunity to have another affair, however he says “...I will cut off my hand before I’;; ever reach for you again” (p. 21). Obviously John Proctor has good morals within his soul, if he has the decency to not continue on the affair that had begun. Classical heros also make mistakes, for example when Spiderman kissed another women other than Mary-Jane. Along with John not continuing the affair with Abigail, he also contains much guilt for what he did, and seeks forgiveness from both his wife, Elizabeth, and himself. He feels as though he has lost his soul from committing such a large sin when he is forced to sign his name confessing he has used witchcraft and he exclaims, “Because it is my name!...How may I live without my name? I have given you my soul; leave my name!” (p. 124). Readers also come across Johns agony in himself when he is speaking to his wife and she is telling him that it was partially her fault for his lechery, and he cries out, “No, I take my own [sins], my own!” (p. 119). Surely a good man should have self-guilt for the pain he had caused his wife to feel, and seek forgiveness from his wife. Overall, John Proctor is definitely a hero for partially his good morals, but there are many others examples that have not been spoken of. 

No comments:

Post a Comment